Man Sues Ex-Fiance For Money Spent On Vasectomy

A Utah Court rejected an ex-fiance's request to recover thousands of dollars he spent during his engagement including those on a vasectomy, a cruise to Alaska, a trip to France and other purchases.

Layne D. Hess sued Jody Johnston after she returned an engagement ring to him in April 2005 and called off a wedding planned for that summer.

Hess accused her of breach of contract, claiming he spent the money because of their upcoming marriage.

The court said: "Hess urges this court to adopt the position that any gift given during the engagement period carries an implied condition of marriage. We decline to do so".

"If we were to imply a condition on all gifts given during the engagement period, every gift would be recoverable regardless of the size, cost, significance or nature of the gift". An engagement, the court said, is a "test period" for people.

"We see no benefit in discouraging or penalizing persons who realize ... for whatever reason they are unprepared to take such an important step", the court said of marriage.

Hess' expenses list included $2,400 which he spent to help Johnston's son buy a car.

Well, at least he got the ring back.

 � Copyright 2004-2015 The News Vault. All rights reserved.